Escalating Medical Negligence in Commonwealth West Africa: Evaluating the Efficacy of Deterrence Mechanism

Ugochukwu Godspower Ehirim

Abstract


Medical malpractice remains a persistent issue across Commonwealth West-African countries, with limited legal interventions to ensure accountability or deter future occurrences. Despite increasing incidents of medical negligence, both Nigeria and Ghana continue to grapple with the challenge of establishing criminal liability in clear-cut cases. This paper examines the emergent jurisprudential shift signaled by Lagos v Orji, which demonstrates the feasibility of invoking criminal law in medical negligence cases—an area traditionally confined to civil and administrative remedies. Employing a doctrinal methodology and drawing on primary and secondary legal sources, the study explores the shared common law heritage and regional leadership roles of Nigeria and Ghana to assess broader trends in West African legal responses to medical negligence. A key finding of the study is the critical role of social media in raising rights-consciousness and exposing malpractice cases that often escape official documentation. The research highlights a troubling dearth of judicial precedents and underdeveloped jurisprudence on the subject, arguing that the severity and frequency of such cases necessitate a shift toward penal deterrence. The paper underscores the urgency of rethinking legal frameworks to ensure medical accountability, proposing the adoption and refinement of Indonesia’s criminal liability model as a potential roadmap. In advocating for the integration of criminal jurisprudence into the discourse on medical negligence, this study offers a novel contribution to legal scholarship and calls for urgent reform in regulatory and prosecutorial approaches within the region.

Keywords


Negligence; Duty of Care; Medical Practitioner; Code of Ethics; Prosecution

Full Text:

PDF

References


A. Adedoyin and S. Omoregie, “Nigeria: Case Review: The State of Lagos v Dr. Ejike Ferdinand Orji (2023),” Mondaq (2023), https://www.mondaq.com/Nigeria/professional-negligence/1330996/case-review-the-state-of-lagos-v-dr-ejike-ferdinand-orji-unreported-decision-in-suit-ld8963c2019#.

A. M. Farrell and E. S. Dove, Mason and McCall Smith’s Law and Medical Ethics, 12th ed. (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2023), 406–412.

A. Sethi and R. Bilgaiyan, “Doctors in Conflict with the Criminal Law: A Records View of Gross Medical Negligence Cases under the Indian Penal Code,” Sri Ramachandra Journal of Health Sciences 4, no. 1 (2024): 6–11, https://doi.org/10.25259/srjhs_50_2023.

Abatan v. Awudu [2014] 17 NWLR (Pt 430) 3 (per Aderemi, JCA).

Abdulsalam, M. “Nigeria: A Review of Medical Negligence in the Nigerian Healthcare Sector: Utilising the Law as a Panacea.” Mondaq, 2023. https://www.mondaq.com/Nigeria/healthcare/1266406/a-review-of-medical-negligence-in-the-nigerian-healthcare-sector-utilising-the-law-as-a-panacea.

Abi v. Central Bank of Nigeria [2012] 3 NWLR (Pt 1286) 1.

Adejumo, O. A., dan O. A. Adejumo. “Legal Perspectives on Liability for Medical Negligence and Malpractices in Nigeria.” Pan African Medical Journal 35 (2020): 1–2.

Agyire Tettey, Kwaku, dan Anor. v. The University of Ghana & 2 Ors [2018], dalam R. N. Obu, “The Worrying State of Medical Negligence in Ghana: Do We Need a Special Healthcare Court to Handle Such Issues?” Modern Ghana (Accra: 14 Juli 2020). https://www.modernghana.com/news/1016025/the-worrying-state-of-medical-negligence-in-ghana.html.

Ajaegbu v. Etuk [1962] 6 E. N. L. R 196.

Akinpelu, D. A., dan S. O. Akintola. “Navigating the Legal and Ethical Terrain of Artificial Intelligence in Enhancing Patient Safety in Nigeria.” Journal of Intellectual Property and Information Technology Law (JIPIT) 3, no. 1 (2023): 176. https://doi.org/10.52907/jipit.v3i1.261.

Alghrami, A., M. R. Patel, D. Ford, A. Brook, A. Fan, D. Vaughan, dan D. Brennan. “Balancing the Scales of Safety: The Criminal Law’s Impact on Patient Safety and Error Reduction.” British Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery 62, no. 3 (2024): 229–32. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.BJOMS.2023.11.018.

Law No. 8 of 1999 (Indonesia).

Law No. 29 of 2004 on Medical Practice (Indonesia).

Asan - Tekramo (Kumah) v. Attorney-General [1975] 1 GLR 319.

Avoseh, J. S. “The Duties and Responsibilities of Medical Practitioner and Liability for the Breach under Nigerian Law.” E-Justice, India, 2020. https://www.ejusticeindia.com/the-duties-and-liability-for-breach-under-nigerian-law/.

Ayenakin, O., T. Akindejoye, dan I. Kolade-Faseyi. “Examination of the Legal Institutional Framework of Medical Law in Nigeria.” Global Journal of Politics and Law Research 9 (2021): 13.

B. T. Bawono, “Restitution Rights as a Construction of Justice Referring to the Law on Protection of Witnesses and Victims,” International Journal of Law Construction 5 (2021): 25.

Bajwa, J., S. Nori, D. M. Patel, S. N. Longhurst, H. L. Segar, dan A. L. Singh. “Artificial Intelligence in Healthcare: Transforming the Practice of Medicine.” Future Healthcare Journal 8, no. 2 (2021): e188–e194. https://doi.org/10.7861/fhj.2021-0095.

Barnett v. Chelsea and Kensington Hospital Management Committee [1969] 1 Q. B. 428.

Bayuo, J., dan A. O. Koduah. “Patterns and Outcomes of Medical Malpractice Cases in Ghana: A Systemic Content Analysis.” Ghana Medical Journal 56, no. 4 (2022): 322–30. https://doi.org/10.4314/gmj.v56i4.11.

Biviji, M. A. v. Sunita and Others, Civil Appeal No. 3975/2018, judgment delivered 19 October 2023 (India).

Bolam v. Friern Hospital Management Committee [1957] 1 WLR 582, 586.

Botchewey, C. O. A., P. D. Boateng, D. Y. Adomako, dan A. Agyekum. “Patient Safety Culture and Satisfaction in Ghana: A Facility-Based Cross-Sectional Study.” BMJ Open 14, no. 1 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2023-073190.

Bourne, T., H. Wynants, M. Peters, B. Van Audenhove, G. Timmerman, S. Vankrunkelsven, dan M. Van Calster. “Doctors’ Experiences and Their Perception of the Most Stressful Aspects of Complaints Processes in the UK: An Analysis of Qualitative Survey Data.” BMJ Open 6, no. e011711 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2016-011711.

C. Crosby, “Gross Negligence Manslaughter Revisited: The Time for a Change of Direction?” The Journal of Criminal Law 84 (2020): 84, https://doi.org/10.1177/0022018320926468.

C. Phillips et al., “Medical Negligence: A Neurosurgeon’s Guide,” Interdisciplinary Neurosurgery 23 (2021): 100970, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.inat.2020.100970; see also R v Rudling [2016] EWCCA Crim 741.

C. V. Odoeme, D. Ugwuja, and C. S. Onah, “Medical Error Litigation in Nigeria: A Proposal for Change,” Journal of Legal Medicine (2023), https://doi.org/10.1080/01947648.2023.2238564.

Case, P., dan G. Sharma. “Promoting Public Confidence in the Medical Profession: Learning from the Case of Dr Bawa-Garba.” Medical Law International 20 (2020): 58–72. https://doi.org/10.1177/0968533220933788.

Chukwuneke, F. N. “Medical Incidents in Developing Countries: A Few Case Studies from Nigeria.” Nigerian Journal of Clinical Practice 18 (2015): 20–24.

Code of Medical Ethics in Nigeria.

Compulsory Treatment and Care for Victims of Gunshots Act 2017 (Nigeria).

Criminal Code of Germany, https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/englisch_stgb/index.html.

D. Pranka, “The Price of Medical Negligence – Should It Be Judged by the Criminal Court in the Context of the Jurisprudence of the European Court of Human Rights?” Baltic Journal of Law and Politics 14 (2021): 126.

Darko v. Karle-bu Teaching Hospital, Suit No. 44/06, Judgment by Accra Fast Track High Court delivered 24 June 2008.

Dauda, M., dan T. I. A. Oseni. “Medical Duty of Care: A Medico-Legal Analysis of Medical Negligence in Nigeria.” American International Journal of Contemporary Research 9 (2019): 60.

Delafontaine, A., S. P. Curley, G. M. Nixon, et al. “Impact of Confrontation to Patient Suffering and Death on Wellbeing and Burnout in Professionals: A Cross-Sectional Study.” BMC Palliative Care 23 (2024). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12904-024-01393-8.

Denloye v. Medical Council Disciplinary Tribunal [1968] All NLR 306.

Denning, A. T. The Discipline of Law. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2013.

Donoghue v. Stevenson [1932] AC 562.

Dr. Ravishankar v. Jerry K. Thomas II, [2006] CPJ 138 (NC) (India).

E. Wolvaardt, “Blame Does Not Keep Patients Safe,” Community Eye Health 32 (2019): 36.

Ezeobi, C. “A Tale of Medical Negligence.” This Day Live (2022). https://www.thisdaylive.com.

Ferorelli, D., G. Fabbri, F. Pippa, G. Nobile, dan V. Lodi. “Medical Legal Aspect of Telemedicine in Italy: Application Fields, Professional Liability and Focus on Care Services during COVID-19 Health Emergency.” Journal of Primary Care & Community Health 11 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1177/2150132720985055.

G. Adshead, “Offending in Theatre: The Case of Ian Peterson,” BMJ 357 (2017): j2583; D. Lee and P. Lai, “Case of Ian Peterson: Reflection and Perspective on Clinical Governance Surgery Practice,” BMJ 22 (2018): 5–9.

G. B. Mensah and A. Addy, “Medical Negligence in the Context of the Ghanaian Criminal Jurisprudence,” International Journal for Multiple Disciplinary Research (IJFMR) 5 (2023): 2.

Gabriel, A. O. “Documentation of Medical Errors in Nigeria: A Review.” Research Square (2024). https://doi.org/10.21203/rs-4002952/v1.

Ghanaian Criminal and Other Offences Act No. 29 of 1960 (Ghana Code).

Griffin, F. “Artificial Intelligence and Liability in Health Care.” Health Matrix: Journal of Law-Medicine 31 (2021): 65–106.

Gyan v. Ashanti Goldfields Corporation [1991] 1 GLR 466.

H. H. Luqmansyah et al., “A Doctor’s Responsibility for Alleged Negligence in Medical Actions,” Asian Journal of Medical Research and Analysis 1 (2024): 97.

H. K. Obaro, “Legal Imperatives of Medical Negligence and Medical Malpractice,” Nigerian Journal of Medicine 31 (2022): 603.

H. S. Tsai et al., “Impact of the Medical Care Act Amendment on Medical Malpractice Litigation in Taiwan,” Medicine 101, no. 46 (2022): e31564, https://doi.org/10.1097/MD.0000000000031564.

Hanganu, B., A. Mănescu, A. D. Firică, dan C. S. Lăzureanu. “Reasons for and Facilitating Factors of Medical Malpractice Complaints: What Can Be Done to Prevent Them?” Medicina 56, no. 259 (2020). https://doi.org/10.3390/medicina56060259.

Hasibuan, F. H., R. D. Siregar, dan I. Syahputra. “The Relationship between Ethics and Institutions in the Health Sector in the Enforcement of Professional Ethics from a Utilitarian Perspective.” AJOMRA 2 (2024): 130–39.

Health Professions Regulatory Bodies Act No. 857 of 2013 (Ghana);

Hedley Byrne & Co. Ltd. v. Heller & Partners Ltd. [1964] AC 465.

Ibitoye, T. R. “The Applicability of the Doctrine of Res Ipsa Loquitor in Medical Negligence in Nigeria.” Nnamdi Azikiwe University Journal of International Law and Jurisprudence 1 (2018): 173.

Imuekemhe, E. J. “An Examination of the Disposition of the Law to Cases of Medical Negligence in Nigeria.” Edo University Law Journal 1 (2018): 13.

Indian Medical Association v. V. P. Shanta III, [1995] CPJ 1 (SC).

Indonesia. Undang-Undang Dasar Republik Indonesia Tahun 1945.

Irehobhue, O., dan N. Remigius. Comparative Health Law and Policy – Critical Perspectives on Nigeria and Global Health Law. 1st ed. (Ashgate Publishing Limited, 2015), 95.

Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab [2005] 6 SCC 1 (India).

Khalid, H. “Legal Protection for Victims of Medical Malpractice during the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Study on Legislation.” SJH 5 (2023): 263–75.

Lungile Ntsele v. MEC for Health, Gauteng Provisional Government [2013] 2 All SA 356 (GSJ).

M. Robson, J. Maskill, and W. Brookbanks, “Doctors Are Aggrieved – Should They Be? Gross Negligence Manslaughter and Culpable Doctor,” The Journal of Criminal Law 84 (2020): 84, https://doi.org/10.1177/0022018320946498.

Maimela, C. A. “Medical Negligence and the Res Ipsa Loquitur Doctrine in the Administration of Cancer Treatment in South Africa.” Obiter 43, no. 1 (2022). https://doi.org/10.17159/obiter.v43i1.13499.

Maini, B., R. Kumar, dan A. K. Dwivedi. “Medical Negligence: A Conceptual Analysis.” Journal of Advanced Zoology 45, no. S2 (2024): 425–32. https://doi.org/10.5355/jaz.v45Is2.5032.

Malhotra, S. “Supreme Court Solidifies the Law on Medical Negligence: Is it the Balanced Position?” The Leaflet (27 November 2023). https://theleaflet.india.

Maulana, A., C. B. E. Praja, dan M. L. Hakim. “Compensation as Hospital Liability for Negligence in Medical Services Harming Patients: Empirical Study of Several Peace Agreements.” Varia Justicia 19 (2023): 153.

MEC for Health, Gauteng v. de Lange [2024] ZASCA 38.

Medical and Dental Practitioners Act, Cap M8, Laws of the Federation of Nigeria (LFN) 2004.

Melley, B. “Alternative Healer Gets 10 Years in UK Prison for Death of Woman at Slap Therapy Workshop.” AP News, December 6, 2024. https://apnews.com/article/britain-slap-therapy-death-insulin-diabetic-california-australia-17b485f9b96d38219613c65c6e48ad0a.

Meyers v. MEC, Department of Health, Eastern Cape [2023] ZASCA 130.

Michael, O. D. “Understanding the Theoretical and Legal Foundations of Medical Negligence Law in Nigeria.” SSRN Electronic Journal (2024). https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4777626.

Mittal v. State of U.P., [1989] AIR SC 1570 (India).

Mohun v. Philips [2022] ZASCA 186.

Muhammad Ghozali, Cut Afra, Deddi Agusriadi, and Sudirman Suti, “Legal Consequences of Medical Accidents and Malpractice in Indonesia,” International Journal of Law, Social Science, and Humanities (IJLSH) 1, no. 2 (2024): https://doi:10.70193/ijlsh.v1i2.159.

N. Gutorova, O. Zhytnyi, and T. Kaganovska, “Medical Negligence Subject to Criminal Law,” Wiadomosci Lekarskie 72, no. 11 cz 1 (2019): 2161–2166, https://doi.org/10.36740/WLek201911118.

National Health Act 2014, Section 23 (Nigeria).

National Revolutionary Council Decree (NRCD) No. 91 of 1972.

National Health Insurance Authority Act (Nigeria), which replaced the National Health Insurance Scheme Act 1999. See also s. 30(1) of the National Health Act 2014; National Health Service Act 1946 (UK), which established the National Health Service in Great Britain.

National Health Service Act 1946 (UK), which established the National Health Service in Great Britain.

Nigeria Criminal Code Act Cap C38 LFN 2004 and Penal Code (Northern States) Federal Provisions Act Cap P3 LFN 2004.

Nurarafah Nurarafah, “Doctor’s Civil Responsibility in Medical Malpractice in Indonesia,” Journal Research of Social Science Economics and Management 1, no. 10 (2022), https://doi.org/10.59141/jrssem.v1i10.175.

O. M. Atoyebi, “Addressing the Need for a More Robust Compensatory Regime in Tackling Cases of Medical Negligence in Nigeria,” (2023), https://www.omaplex.com.ng.

Obu, R. N. “Resolving the Medical Negligence Quagmire in Ghana: Some Suggested Solutions.” News Ghana (2022). https://newsghana.com.gh/resolving-the-medical-negligence-quagmire-in-ghana-some-suggested-solutins/.

Odunsi, B. “Medical Negligence and Its Litigation in Nigeria.” Beijing Law Review 14 (2023): 1090–1122.

Ogundare, B. “Medical Negligence in Nigeria: A Quick Guide on Liabilities and Remedies.” Social Sciences Research Network (SSRN) (2019). https://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3476524.

Ojo v. Gharoro & Others [2006] 10 NWLR (Pt 987) 173 [SC].

Okekearu v. Tanko [2002] 15 NWLR (Pt 791) 657 [SC].

Okezie v. Chairman, Medical and Dental Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal [2010] JELR 49389 (CA).

Okonkwo v. Medical and Dental Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal (MDPRT) [2001] 7 NWLR (Pt 711) 206.

Olowo v. Nigerian Navy [2011] 18 NWLR (Pt 1279) 659 (SC).

Oluwadamilola, F. “The Cultured Hell of Medical Negligence in Nigeria.” Foundation for Investigative Journalism (Lagos, 5 Agustus 2023). https://fij.ng. Penulis mengemukakan bahwa 42,8% dari 145 tenaga medis di Nigeria terlibat dalam kelalaian medis.

Onwuzoo, A. “Costly Error: Tales of Patients Killed, Disabled by Health Workers’ Negligence.” Punch (Lagos, October 1, 2023). https://punching.com.

Onyekwere, J. “Menace and Consequences of Medical Negligence in Nigeria.” The Guardian (Lagos: 21 Februari 2023). https://guardian.ng.

Otti v. Excel – C Medical Centre Ltd & Anor [2019] LPELR – 47699 (CA).

P. Voultsos, G. Ricci, V. Tambone, et al., “A Proposal for Limited Criminal Liability in High-Accuracy Endoscopic Sinus Surgery,” Acta Otorhinolaryngologica Italica 37 (2017), https://doi.org/10.14639/0392-100x-1292.

Panagioti, M., I. Khan, E. Keers, D. Abuzour, M. Phipps, S. Kontopantelis, R. Bower, R. Campbell, and S. A. Vinogradova. “Preventive, Severity and Nature of Preventable Patient Harm Across Medical Care Settings: Systemic Review and Meta-Analysis.” BMJ 366, no. l4185 (2019): 390. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.l4185.

People of the State of California v. Conrad Robert Murray, No. B237677 (Cal. Ct. App. 2011).

R v Adamako [1994] UKHL 6.

R v Akerele [1942] 8 WACA 5.

R v Lawanta [1961] Western Nigerian Law Reports 133.

R v Ozegbe [1957] 1 Western Nigerian Law Reports 152.

R v. Bawa-Garba [2016] EWCA Crim 1841.

R v. Hongchi Xiao [2024].

R. Abujah, “LASG Commended for Convicting Doctor in Landmark Medical Negligence Case,” Science Nigeria (2023), https://sciencenigeria.com/lasg-commended-for-convicting-doctor-in-landmark-medical-negligenc-case.

R. N. Obu, “The Worrying State of Medical Negligence in Ghana: Do We Need A Special Healthcare Court to Handle Such Issues?” Modern Ghana (Accra: 14 June, 2020), https://www.modernghana.com/news/1016025/the-worrying-state-of-medical-negligence-in-ghana.html.

R. Rinaldi, “The Italian Supreme Court Joint Sections Set Forth the Interpretative Underpinnings of the ‘Gelli-Bianco’ Law: Varying Degrees of Guilt Aimed at Limiting Medical Liability, Article 2236 C.C. Makes a Comeback,” La Clinica Terapeutica 171, no. 2 (2020): e101–106, https://doi.org/10.7417/CT.2020.2197.

Rose v R [2017] EWCA Crim 1168.

Ruggie, J. G. “The Social Construction of the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights.” In Research Handbook on Human Rights and Business, edited by Surya Deva and David Birchall, 63–86. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing, 2020.

Saripan, H., M. H. A. Bakar, dan A. R. M. Shahar. “Artificial Intelligence and Medical Negligence in Malaysia: Confronting the Informed Consent Dilemma.” International Journal of Academic Research in Business & Social Sciences 11 (2021): 293–302.

Shakoor v. Situ [2001] 1 WLR 410.

Sidi, R. “Legal Responsibility for Medical Risks and Medical Negligence in the View of Health Law.” Journal of General Education Science 2 (2023): 106.

Somi v. Tema General Hospital [1994–2000] CHRAJ 196.

State of Lagos v Dr. Ejike Ferdinand Orji (Unreported Suit No: LD/8963C/2019: Judgment Delivered 20 January 2023 by Hon. Justice A. A. Akintoye of Lagos High Court, Lagos).

State v Kwaku Nkyi [1962] GLR 197.

State v Okechukwu [1965] E.N.L.R. 91.

Tawiah, O. “Cases of Medical Negligence in Ghana on the Rise.” My Joy Online (2022). https://www.myjoyonline.com/cases-of-medical-negligence-in-ghana-on-the-rise/.

the Ghanaian Criminal and Other Offences Act No. 29 of 1960

U. G. Ehirim et al., “Strengthening Human Rights Protection in Nigeria: Safeguards Under the Police Act 2020,” Khazanah Hukum 6, no. 3 (2024): 269–293, https://doi.org/10.15575/KH.V6I3.39569.

Ukiri, C. E. “Medical Negligence Caused the Tragic Death of Twin Infants Born on 3 October 2023 at Ikorodu General Hospital.” The Bar and Bench News (2023). https://www.thebarandbenchnews.com.

Unilorin v. Abegunde [2015] 3 NWLR 421.

University of Ilorin Teaching Hospital v. Mrs. Theresa Akilo [2000] 22 WRN 117.

University of Nigeria Teaching Hospital Management Board v. Hope Nnoli [1994] 8 NWLR (Pt 365) 367, 395–396.

V. Sameera, A. Bindra, and G. Rath, “Human Errors and Their Prevention in Healthcare,” Journal of Anaesthesiology Clinical Pharmacology 37 (2021): 328–335, https://doi.org/10.4103/joacp.JOACP_364_19.

Violato, D. “Doctor-Patient Relationships, Laws, Clinical Guidelines, Best Practices, Evidence-Based Medicine, Medical Errors and Patient Safety.” Canadian Medical Education Journal 4 (2013). https://www.researchgate.net.

W. Glauser, “Should Medical Errors Ever Be Considered Criminal Offences?” CMAJ 190 (2018).

Wicaksono, P., R. A. Gunawan, I. R. P. Putra, dan H. Y. Prasetyo. “Quo Vadis: Legal Certainty of Informal Worker through Manpower Act.” Jurnal Cendekia Hukum 8 (2023): 301.

Wulandari, S., dan University of 17 Agustus 1945 Semarang. “Legal Formulation Patient Protection in Medical Malpractice.” International Journal of Social Science and Human Research 6 (2023). https://doi.org/10.47191/ijsshr/v6-i5-88.

Wulandari, S., dan University of 17 Agustus 1945 Semarang. “Legal Formulation Patient Protection in Medical Malpractice.” International Journal of Social Science and Human Research 6 (2023). https://doi.org/10.47191/ijsshr/v6-i5-88.

Y. Prayuti et al., “Judicial Analysis of Legal Protection for Malpractice Victims by Hospitals in Patients with Brain Stem Death,” UNES Law Review 6, no. 2 (2023), https://doi.org/10.31933/unesrev.v6i2.

Yadav, J., M. Yadav, dan S. Chand. “Medical Negligence and Its Determinants.” International Journal of Recent Scientific Research 11 (2020): 40080–82.




DOI: https://doi.org/10.33756/jelta.v18i1.30084

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.