Constitutional Court’s Role in Regional Head Election Disputes: Substantive Justice and Voting Threshold Challenges

Fathullah Fathullah, Mohamad Hidayat Muhtar, Yustiana Yustiana, Saharuddin Saharuddin, Rio Akmal Syahbana

Abstract


This study examines the Constitutional Court's authority in resolving regional head election disputes, focusing on its role in ensuring substantive justice and the implications of the vote threshold in Article 158 of the Regional Head Election Law on candidates' constitutional rights. The research employs a normative legal method, utilizing a statutory approach to analyze the Court’s jurisdiction, a case approach to assess key decisions, and a conceptual approach to evaluate the principles of substantive justice in electoral disputes. Primary legal sources include the 1945 Indonesian Constitution and Constitutional Court rulings, while secondary sources consist of scholarly literature, legal commentaries, and tertiary legal references. The findings reveal that the Constitutional Court has played a pivotal role in upholding democratic principles by setting aside formalistic constraints such as the vote threshold when structured, systematic, and massive violations significantly impact election outcomes. However, this approach raises concerns regarding the consistency of judicial rulings and legal certainty. Additionally, the study highlights that Article 158 often limits candidates’ access to legal remedies, restricting their ability to contest elections despite substantial evidence of electoral fraud. The study contributes to the academic discourse on electoral justice by demonstrating how legal formalism can undermine substantive justice in democratic processes. It recommends revising Article 158 to introduce an exception mechanism that balances procedural efficiency with fairness, thereby enhancing the legitimacy and integrity of regional head elections. This reform is essential to ensure a more equitable electoral dispute resolution system that safeguards both democratic accountability and legal certainty.

Keywords


Constitutional Court; Regional Head Elections; Voting Threshold; Substantive Justice.

Full Text:

PDF

References


Abqa, Muhammad Ardhi Razaq, MH SH, S. H. Dedi Mulyadi, MH Moh Mujibur Rohman, S. H. Mia Amalia, MH Jeferson Tanesab, S. Sos, S. H. Junaidi, and CLA MH. POLITIK HUKUM PEMILU. JAMBI: PT. Sonpedia Publishing Indonesia, 2023. https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Mohamad-Hidayat-Muhtar/publication/371735353_Penerbit/links/6492eb86b9ed6874a5c549fc/Penerbit.pdf.

Amer, Nabih, Arief Fahmi Lubis, Mohamad Hidayat Muhtar, Vica Jillyan Edsti Saija, Viorizza Suciani Putri, and Beni Setiawan. ‘IMPLICATIONS OF THE CONSTITUTION FOR POLITICAL NEUTRALITY IN THE DYNAMICS OF LAW AND DEMOCRACY’. Journal de Facto 10, no. 2 (28 January 2024): 283–302. https://doi.org/10.36277/jurnaldefacto.v10i2.189.

Aspinall, Edward. ‘Oligarchic Populism: Prabowo Subianto’s Challenge to Indonesian Democracy’. Indonesia, no. 99 (2015): 1–28. https://doi.org/10.5728/indonesia.99.0001.

Boryslavska, Olena, and Miroslaw Granat. ‘Independence of Constitutional Justices: Stumbling Blocks in Ukraine and Poland’. Access to Just. E. Eur., 2021, 8.

Chandra, M. Jeffri Arlinandes, and Jamaludin Ghafur. ‘Peranan Hukum Dalam Mencegah Praktik Politik Uang (Money Politics) Dalam Pemilu Di Indonesia: Upaya Mewujudkan Pemilu Yang Berintegritas’. Wajah Hukum 4, no. 1 (24 April 2020): 52–66. https://doi.org/10.33087/wjh.v4i1.167.

Ferza, Ray, and Nuril Fikri Aulia. ‘2018 Simultaneous Regional Head Elections: Political Dowry and Policy Implication’. Jurnal Bina Praja 12, no. 1 (28 May 2020): 11–20. https://doi.org/10.21787/jbp.12.2020.11-20.

Harahap, Tuti Khairani, Yuyut Prayuti, Nining Latianingsih, Amsari Damanik, Tiyas Maheni, Ida Farida, Mohamad Hidayat Muhtar, and Mustaqim. ‘PENGANTAR ILMU HUKUM’. Penerbit Tahta Media, 30 May 2023. https://tahtamedia.co.id/index.php/issj/article/view/255.

Huq, Aziz, and Tom Ginsburg. ‘How to Lose a Constitutional Democracy’. UCLA Law Review 65 (2018): 78.

Indra, Mexsasai, Geofani Milthree Saragih, and Mohamad Hidayat Muhtar. ‘Strength of Constitutional Court Decisions in Judicial Review of the 1945 Constitution in Indonesia: Kekuatan Putusan Mahkamah Konstitusi Dalam Pengujian Undang-Undang Terhadap Undang-Undang Dasar 1945 Di Indonesia’. Jurnal Konstitusi 20, no. 2 (1 June 2023): 279–99. https://doi.org/10.31078/jk2026.

Joshi, Devin K. ‘Lawyers and Law Graduates in Parliaments as a Consequence of SMD Electoral Systems: A Comparison of Japan, South Korea, and Germany’. Japanese Journal of Political Science 21, no. 1 (March 2020): 19–30. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1468109919000112.

Kelliher, Camden, Saldi Isra, Yuliandri, Zainul Daulay, Hilaire Tegnan, and Feri Amsari. ‘Unconstitutional Authority of Indonesia’s Constitutional Court: The Resolution of Pilkada Result Disputes’. Election Law Journal: Rules, Politics, and Policy 18, no. 3 (September 2019): 297–308. https://doi.org/10.1089/elj.2018.0535.

Kurnia, Titon Slamet. ‘Prediktabilitas Ajudikasi Konstitusional: Mahkamah Konstitusi Dan Pengujian Undang-Undang’. Jurnal Konstitusi 13, no. 2 (27 August 2016): 259–77. https://doi.org/10.31078/jk1322.

Muhtar, Mohamad Hidayat, Abdul Kahar Maranjaya, Nur Arfiani, and Erman Rahim. TEORI & HUKUM KONSTITUSI : Dasar Pengetahuan dan Pemahaman serta Wawasan Pemberlakuan Hukum Konstitusi di Indonesia. PT. Sonpedia Publishing Indonesia, 2023.

Muhtar, Mohamad Hidayat, Didik Suhariyanto, Dedi Mulyadi, Moh Rohman, Mia Amalia, Jeferson Tanesab, M Junaidi, and C Muhamad. ‘IUS CONTITUTUM (ATURAH HUKUM POSITIF PEMILU)’, 22–34, 2023.

Muhtar, Mohamad Hidayat, Ichlas Tribakti, Agus Salim, Harry A. Tuhumury, M. Hasan Ubaidillah, Suwitno Y. Imran, Iskandar Laka, et al. Konsep Hukum Indonesia. Global Eksekutif Teknologi, 2023.

Nasution, Faiz Albar, Muhammad Husni Thamrin, Randa Putra Kasea Sinaga, Muhammad Imanuddin Kandias Saraan, and Yofiendi Indah Indainanto. ‘Humbang Hasundutan Regional Head Election In 2020: Empty Box Volunteer Political Communication Movement’. Studies in Media and Communication 11, no. 1 (2023): 52–59.

Perdana, M. Taufan, Moh Alfaris, and Anik Iftitah. ‘Kewenangan Bawaslu Dalam Pilkada 2020 Pasca Putusan Mahkamah Konstitusi Nomor 48/PUU-XVII/2019’. Jurnal Supremasi, 31 March 2020, 1–11. https://doi.org/10.35457/supremasi.v10i1.940.

Pujayanti, Luh Putu Vera Astri, Zainun Zakya Nugrahayu, Erman I. Rahim, Mohamad Hidayat Muhtar, and Chami Yassine. ‘Indonesia’s Constitutional Court: Bastion of Law Enforcement and Protector of Human Rights in The Reform Era’. Jurnal Pamator : Jurnal Ilmiah Universitas Trunojoyo 17, no. 1 (26 February 2024): 35–49. https://doi.org/10.21107/pamator.v17i1.24128.

Razak, Askari, Mohamad Hidayat Muhtar, Kevin M. Rivera, and Geofani Milthree Saragih. ‘Balancing Civil and Political Rights: Constitutional Court Powers in Indonesia and Austria’. Journal of Indonesian Legal Studies 8, no. 2 (12 December 2023): 1311–60. https://doi.org/10.15294/jils.v8i2.70717.

Risyat, Aisyah, Riska Muliani, and Muhammad Erfa Redhani. ‘CONSTITUTIONAL JURISDICTION REVIEW OF THE EXISTENCE OF INDIGENOUS LAW COMMUNITIES IN INDONESIA’. Constitutional Law Society 1, no. 1 (2 April 2022): 25–40. https://doi.org/10.36448/cls.v1i1.6.

Setiadi, Wicipto, Diani Sadiawati, Aurora Jillena Meliala, Handar Subhandi Bakhtiar, and Beniharmoni Harefa. ‘The Role of Indonesia Constitutional Court Decision in the Process of Establishing the Law: A Case Study in the Process of Establishing the Law on General Elections’. Journal of Legal, Ethical and Regulatory Issues 24 (2021): 1.

Suwito, Deni Setiyawan, Mohamad Hidayat Muhtar, and Ahmad. ‘Contemplating the Morality of Law Enforcement in Indonesia’. Journal of Law and Sustainable Development 11, no. 10 (25 October 2023): e1261–e1261. https://doi.org/10.55908/sdgs.v11i10.1261.

Syaidi, Ridwan, Zainal Arifin Hoesein, and Ahmad Redi. ‘Resolution of Disputes Over The Regional Head Elections Post The Constitutional Court Decision Number 85/PUUXX/2022 Regarding The Implementation of Simultaneous Regional Elections in Indonesia’. Eduvest - Journal of Universal Studies 4, no. 3 (20 March 2024): 1396–1412. https://doi.org/10.59188/eduvest.v4i3.1132.

Ulum, Muhammad Bahrul. ‘How Democracy Is Election? Reassessing Article 18 (4) of the 1945 Constitution and Its Implication to the Regional Head Election in Indonesia’. Jurnal Hukum Dan Peradilan 8, no. 2 (2019): 315–32.

Widodo, Ibnu Sam, Mohamad Hidayat Muhtar, Didik Suhariyanto, Deni Yusup Permana, Chairul Bariah, Muhammad Fajar Sidiq Widodo, Josef Mario Monteiro, et al. Hukum Tata Negara. Sada Kurnia Pustaka, 2023.

Wutoy, Maichel, Eliyunus Waruwu, Ayler Beniah Ndraha, and Alwi Al Hadad. ‘Application of the Presidential Threshold Concept in the Presidential and Vice-Presidential Election System and Its Impact on the Indonesian Constitutional System’. Journal of Digitainability, Realism & Mastery (DREAM) 1, no. 03 (2022): 46–55.

Yustikaningrum, Rima Yuwana, and Mohammad Mahrus Ali. ‘Dari Sekadau Ke Sabu Raijua: Menakar Jejak Bawaslu Dalam Dinamika Persidangan Di Mahkamah Konstitusi’. Jurnal Konstitusi 18, no. 4 (2021): 918–38.




DOI: https://doi.org/10.33756/jelta.v18i1.30680

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.