Comparison of Political and Legal Dynamics in the Impeachment Process: A Case Study of Indonesia and Brazil

Kevin Rivera; Muhammad Iqbal Mustapa

doi:10.33756/eslaj.v7i3.31090

Comparison of Political and Legal Dynamics in the Impeachment Process: A Case Study of Indonesia and Brazil

Kevin Rivera, Muhammad Iqbal Mustapa

Abstract

Impeachment is a constitutional mechanism in presidential systems designed to hold presidents accountable, yet its execution is often shaped by political dynamics rather than purely legal considerations. This study compares the impeachment cases of Indonesia’s President Abdurrahman Wahid (2001) and Brazil’s President Dilma Rousseff (2016), revealing how political interests significantly influenced both processes. In Indonesia, Wahid’s removal stemmed largely from executive-legislative tensions and party-political maneuvering, with weak legal grounds. In Brazil, Rousseff’s impeachment was driven by intense government-opposition conflict, amplified by media narratives and public opinion, leading to heightened polarization. Despite constitutional frameworks, both cases illustrate how impeachment can be weaponized as a political tool rather than a legal safeguard. The study highlights the blurred boundary between law and politics in impeachment proceedings and underscores its consequences for democratic stability and institutional credibility. Findings suggest that when impeachment is motivated by partisan agendas, it risks eroding public trust in legal institutions and weakening governance. To preserve democratic integrity, impeachment processes must adhere to principles of objectivity, transparency, and fairness, ensuring they serve accountability not political expediency.

Keywords

Impeachment; Political Dynamics; Indonesia; Brazil

Full Text:

PDF

References

Atikah, Ika. “Metode Penelitian Hukum,” 2022. http://repository.uinbanten.ac.id/9155/1/P%20Metode%20Penelitian%20Hukum.pdf.

Bariyyah, Indah Khoiril. “Studi Komparatif Proses Impeachment Presiden Dalam Sistem Ketatanegaraan Indonesia Dan Iran.” Accessed February 10, 2025. https://repository.uinjkt.ac.id/dspace/handle/123456789/32472.

Basri, Abdul Rahman, Muhammad Sawir, Santrio Kamaluddin, and Rhina Pongtuluran. “Lanskap Pemerintahan: Memahami Perbedaan Dan Implikasi Sistem Presidensial, Parlementer, Dan Semi Presidensial.” Journal of Governance and Local Politics (JGLP) 6, no. 1 (May 15, 2024): 63–73. https://doi.org/10.47650/jglp.v6i1.1257.

Budidarmo, Widodo. “Dinamika Politik Pasca Amandemen UUD NRI 1945: Evaluasi Pemakzulan Presiden Berdasarkan Putusan Justisil Dan Keputusan Politik.” UNES Law Review 6, no. 2 (2023): 7146–52.

Guswara, Arrafi Bima, and Ali Imran Nasution. “Dinamika Konstitusionalitas Undang-Undang Cipta Kerja Pasca Putusan Mahkamah Konstitusi Nomor 91/PUU-XVIII/2020 dan 54/PUU-XXI/2023.” JURNAL USM LAW REVIEW 6, no. 3 (November 24, 2023): 1052–72. https://doi.org/10.26623/julr.v6i3.7844.

Hidayat, Fauzan. “The Politik Uang Dalam Sistem Politik Demokratis: Studi Kasus Korea Selatan Dan Negara-Negara Eropa.” Bestuurskunde: Journal of Governmental Studies 4, no. 2 (2024): 101–14.

Jalal, Asran. “Sistem Presidensial Indonesia Masa Kepemimpinan Presiden Soesilo Bambang Yudhoyono (2004-2014).” Populis : Jurnal Sosial Dan Humaniora 6, no. 2 (September 23, 2021): 166–84. https://doi.org/10.47313/pjsh.v6i2.1256.

Kristal, Damar. “Perbandingan (De)Konsolidasi Demokrasi Studi Penurunan Kualitas Demokrasi Di Indonesia Dengan Filipina Periode 2016-2020.” bachelorThesis, Fakultas Ilmu Sosial dan Ilmu Politik, Universitas Islam Negeri (UIN) Syarif Hidayatullah Jakarta, 2021. https://repository.uinjkt.ac.id/dspace/handle/123456789/60020.

Lating, Tazkir Harun Al-Rasyid. “Proporsional Keanggotaan Dewan Perwakilan Daerah Republik Indonesia Terhadap Proses Pemakzulan Presiden Dan/Atau Wakil Presiden Dalam Undang-Undang Dasar Negara Republik Indonesia Tahun 1945.” bachelorThesis, Fakultas Syariah dan Hukum UIN Syarif Hidayatullah Jakarta, 2024. https://repository.uinjkt.ac.id/dspace/handle/123456789/79851.

Mp, H. Muhamad Rezky Pahlawan, Mohamad Fandrian Adhistianto, and Bhanu Prakash Nunna. “Disobedience of Constitutional Court Decision as a Reason for Impeachment of President and Vice President.” Al-Risalah: Forum Kajian Hukum Dan Sosial Kemasyarakatan 24, no. 1 (June 30, 2024): 70–85. https://doi.org/10.30631/alrisalah.v24i1.1509.

Prabowo, Edi. “Mekanisme Pemakzulan (Impeachment) Presiden (Studi Perbandingan Negara Indonesia Dan Brasil).” JIL: Journal of Indonesian Law 1, no. 2 (2020): 119–44.

Pratama, Aditya Andela, Syaif Al Haq, and Adelia Mizani Qisti. “Urgensi Pembentukan Undang-Undang Lembaga Kepresidenan Dalam Mewujudkan Pemilihan Umum Berintegritas Di Indonesia.” JIL : Journal of Indonesian Law 5, no. 2 (December 15, 2024): 158–78. https://doi.org/10.18326/jil.v5i2.2601.

Pratama, Farhan Tulus, and Ninuk Wijiningsih. “Perbandingan Pemberhentian Presiden Dalam Masa Jabatan Di Indonesia Dan Brasil: Comparison of Presidential Terminations in Terms Occupations in Indonesian and Brazil.” AMICUS CURIAE 1, no. 2 (2024): 673–85. https://doi.org/10.25105/amicus.v1i2.19795.

Rohmah, Elva Imeldatur, and Dewi Kartika Sari. “Mekanisme Pemakzulan Presiden Sebelum Dan Sesudah Terbentuknya Mahkamah Konstitusi Di Indonesia.” As-Shahifah : Journal of Constitutional Law and Governance 2, no. 2 (December 29, 2022): 164–201. https://doi.org/10.19105/asshahifah.v2i2.6955.

Saifulloh, Putra Perdana Ahmad, Amancik Amancik, and Sonia Ivana Barus. “Penataan Ulang Pencabutan Peraturan Pemerintah Pengganti Undang-Undang Dalam Sistem Ketatanegaraan Indonesia.” Jurnal Hukum Sasana 10, no. 1 (June 8, 2024): 84–100. https://doi.org/10.31599/sasana.v10i1.1226.

Saputra, Dimas Surya. “Faktor Kegagalan Unión De Naciones Suramericana (Unasur) Terhadap Integrasi Regional Di Amerika Selatan Tahun 2008-2020,” September 16, 2022. https://dspace.uii.ac.id/handle/123456789/40847.

Sari, Winda, Fitra Arsil, Nurul Insi Syahruddin, and Desi Fitriyani. “Presidential Inauguration: Pertanggungjawaban Presiden Indonesia Dalam Prosedur dan Materi Sumpah Jabatan.” Al-Daulah : Jurnal Hukum Pidana dan Ketatanegaraan 12, no. 2 (December 15, 2023): 184–207. https://doi.org/10.24252/ad.vi.41577.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.33756/eslaj.v7i3.31090